(Note: I first wrote this for Amazon.com book review section, and decided to include it here.I have made some spelling corrections but otherwise this is exactly how it appears on Amazon.com)
Animals in Translation: Using the Mysteries of Autism to Decode Animal Behavior (Temple Grandian)
This book is engagingly written. It is, however, quite full of factual
inaccuracies. This is the first book in nearly a decade I declined to
finish because of the level of inaccuracies. There are the minor ones
(for example, she refers to insects as not animals - she meant they
were not mammals, I think) that show sloppy editorial review. There are
also substantial ones (for example, she refers to the collie breed as
being stupid because poor genetics have morphed their brain case; this
is a theory first put forth around 1900 and conclusively disproved
numerous times, and is now considered entirely discredited). Even her
description of cattle behavior, a topic on which she has substantial
traction, is apparently dangerously inaccurate according to two friends
who grew up on dairy farms.
While the book is engagingly written the number of substantive
factual errors suggest the best thing you can do with this book is
discard it. Ms. Grandin is well respected in the field of autism
research, I hope she is a lot more careful talking about autism.